Seniors are a rapidly growing demographic in Canada. Average life expectancy of Canadians is rising and by 2036, seniors have been projected to account for between 23% to 25% of the Canadian population. Research conducted by the MFDA indicates that clients 65 years of age or older account for 21% of all households serviced by MFDA Members and 34% of Member Assets Under Administration (“AUA”). The MFDA is committed to addressing issues impacting senior investors and assisting Members and Approved Persons in servicing this important segment of Canadian investors.
MFDA Members have been seeking enhanced guidance and education on serving aging investors and vulnerable clients, as expressed through the MFDA Member Outreach Initiative (see MFDA Bulletin #0792 – M). In response, MFDA staff is developing additional tools and guidance on servicing and protecting senior investors, including holding a third Seniors Summit on October 30, 2019.
This bulletin provides guidance on practices that can be implemented to assist in the protection of seniors and vulnerable clients. In addition, attached at Appendix “A” are the key learnings from the 2015 Seniors Summit which will be updated with further information from the 2019 Seniors Summit. We encourage Members to review these materials.
II. Practices to protect seniors and vulnerable clients
MFDA staff have observed practices at certain Members related to the protection of seniors and vulnerable clients, specifically: (1) requesting clients to name a trusted contact person (TCP); and (2) placing a temporary hold on transactions where there are reasonable concerns regarding financial exploitation of a client or a client’s mental capacity. Set out below are recommendations in respect of TCP and placing temporary holds on transactions, based on these practices.
Trusted Contact Person
Members may consider taking reasonable steps to obtain the name and contact information of a TCP from their clients. A Member that decides to implement a TCP process should consider asking Approved Persons to request their clients to name a TCP at the time of account opening, and to confirm or update the TCP information periodically; for example, during a KYC update.
Members and Approved Persons should be aware that the TCP is a complement to, and not a substitute for, a Power of Attorney (POA). The TCP does not have decision making power with respect to, or authority to effect changes to, the client’s account by virtue of being the TCP.
Contacting a TCP could be of assistance to Members in situations where, among others, there are concerns that a client is being financially exploited or concerns regarding the client’s mental capacity.
When obtaining a TCP, Members should provide the client with written notice of the circumstances in which a TCP may be contacted and obtain the client’s written consent to disclose any personal information that may be shared with the TCP in those situations, as required by MFDA Rule 2.1.3 (Confidential Information) and privacy legislation.
The TCP should be an individual over the age of majority. As a matter of good practice, the TCP should generally not be an individual who has an interest in the client’s account and should not be involved in making financial decisions with respect to the account, such as a POA. Members and Approved Persons should encourage their clients to name different individuals as their TCP and POA, however, it is recognized that this may not be possible for all clients.
When a decision is made to contact a TCP, Members should consider whether other relevant parties such as the MFDA, the police or an office of a public guardian or trustee in the relevant jurisdiction should be contacted.
The following outlines guidance on the general MFDA approach to placing temporary holds on transactions in the circumstances set out below.
Members may develop policies and procedures to enable the dealer to place a temporary hold on a transaction where there is a reasonable concern that financial exploitation of the senior or vulnerable client is taking place, or will take place, or a reasonable concern regarding the mental capacity of the client related to financial decision making. The obligation to deal fairly, honestly and in good faith with clients pursuant to MFDA Rule 2.1.1 (Standard of Conduct) applies when placing temporary holds.
The decision by a Member to place a temporary hold should only be made by authorized and qualified supervisory and compliance staff. Approved Persons who believe that a temporary hold should be placed on a transaction should follow their Member’s policies and procedures regarding the placement of temporary holds by the Member.
Members that place temporary holds should have policies and procedures in place to address matters that include identifying supervisory and compliance staff authorized to: (1) place a temporary hold on behalf of the Member; (2) review, monitor or address the issues in relation to the hold; and (3) decide to complete or disallow the transaction subject to the temporary hold.
When the Member makes the decision to place a temporary hold, the Member or Approved Person should notify the client, and where appropriate, contact the TCP and any parties authorized to transact on the account, such as a POA, as quickly as possible. The temporary hold should not last longer than necessary to address the concern and the Member or Approved Person should update the client as necessary.
In an effort to resolve the matter as quickly as possible, the review of the concern that prompted the hold should begin on a timely basis. Once the review has been completed, the Member should make the decision to complete or disallow the relevant transaction and notify the client.
Members and Approved Persons are reminded that they should maintain appropriate documentation and records in sufficient detail to evidence the following: (1) the reasonable concerns that prompted the temporary hold; (2) the review conducted; and (3) its conclusion.
Next Steps on TCP and Temporary Holds
Further discussion of TCP and temporary holds will take place at the 2019 Seniors Summit on October 30, 2019. MFDA staff advises that it is also currently developing additional guidance and resources in this area.
In addition, the MFDA is actively engaged with the CSA in developing a flexible and responsive regulatory approach to address issues of financial exploitation and diminished mental capacity among seniors and vulnerable clients.
2015 MFDA Seniors Summit
Medico-legal Issues in Servicing Senior Clients
- Dr. Carole Cohen, MDCM, Psychiatrist – Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre
- Arthur Fish, Partner – Borden Ladner Gervais LLP
Summary: Dr. Carole Cohen and Arthur Fish discuss the medical and legal implications of capacity when dealing with senior clients. Dr. Cohen provides red-flags and indicators that may identify a mental capacity issue, and Arthur Fish discusses how to deal with capacity issues from a legal context.
Part A – Medical Issues
Diminished Capacity is a complex medical/legal construct. It is situation specific, meaning it is not an all or nothing concept and it is often related to the specific task or issue in question. For example, an individual may lack the capacity to make financial decisions but may still maintain capacity to make health decisions. Even a diagnosis of dementia does not in itself mean that a person lacks capacity to make decisions. The focus always has to be on the specific context and the facts.
Approved Persons cannot make a determination as to whether an individual lacks mental capacity, however, there are red-flags to be aware of that may indicate mental capacity issues.
Diminished Capacity – Red Flags
Consider the four “C”s
- Context – Does the person understand their situation?
- Choices – Does the person understand their choices?
- Consequences – Does the person understand the ramifications of their choices?
- Consistency – Does the person make a consistent choice?
Red Flag Examples
- Changes from previous behaviors, thinking, attitudes
- Inconsistent and unusual instructions
- Changes in decision-making (particularly if unusual for that person)
- “Head turning sign” – when client constantly turns head to prompt person they are with for reassurance or to provide response
- Not understanding technical terms despite explanations
- Vague responses; e.g. responds “yes” to complex questions, head nodding but little else
- Difficulty keeping facts straight
Elder Financial Abuse
There is an increased risk of financial abuse and exploitation among older clients. The abuse is more likely to be carried out by family members or caregivers than strangers.
Risk Factors for Financial Abuse
- Social isolation
- Dependence on another to provide care
- Financially responsible for adult child or spouse
- Alcohol or drug abuse
- Depression or mental illness
- Increased age
Observable Red Flags
- Cognitive problems
- Fearful, emotionally unstable, or distressed
- Suspicious, delusional
- Change in appearance, poor hygiene
- Accompanied by caregiver who is overly protective; dominates client
Questions you can ask the client
- Who manages your money day-to-day? How is that going?
- Do you run out of money at the end of the month?
- Do you regret or worry about financial decisions you have recently made?
- Have you given Power of Attorney (POA) to another person recently? (Could be a concern if there has been a recent change or appointment)
- Do you have a Will? Has anyone asked you to change it recently?
Part B – Legal Issues
When a POA is in place, it is important to remember that the appointed attorney has fiduciary responsibilities towards the client and that there could be legal exposure to knowingly participating in a breach of that fiduciary duty. For example, processing a large redemption requested by a POA that is clearly not for the benefit of the client.
First question you should ask when POA is presented is “why?”. It is also important to clarify who reporting should go to once a POA is in place and to set timelines for how long the POA will be in place. These may differ depending on the reason for the POA. (e.g. client away on vacation vs. client is losing capacity). If a POA is being put in place because of loss of capacity this would be a time to update KYC information.
Advising During Retirement
- Preet Banerjee
- Dan Hallett, Vice-President & Principal – HighView Financial Group
- Martin Leclair, Vice-President – Proteus
- Jim Otar – RetirementOptimizer.com
Summary: Panel members discuss challenges associated with advising retirees and explore strategies for advising during the decumulation phase.
- Market performance, particularly in the early years of retirement has a significant effect during the decumulation phase. This is particularly true of withdrawal rates between 3% and 6%
- Typical withdrawal rates are often not realistic when matched against client retirement lifestyle needs
- Clients may need to realize that changes in lifestyle may be required to achieve financial goals
- Documenting discussions is of the utmost importance during client retirement, and reviews and updates to plans should be done more frequently in retirement
Facing Elder Financial Abuse – Effective Compliance Programs for Seniors
Delivered by: Ron Long, Director of Regulatory and Elder Client Initiatives – Wells Fargo Advisors, LLC
Watch: Facing Elder Financial Abuse
Summary: Mr. Long provides an overview of his firm’s compliance practices related to detecting and preventing elder financial abuse.
- Best practices include training for all employees on seniors issues and a centralized compliance unit to deal with seniors issues
- Do not be afraid to have candid conversations about memory and dementia-like symptoms with the appropriate clients
- Challenging areas for firms and advisors:
- Familial disputes
- POA abuse
- 3rd party investment scams
- Dementia / Diminished capacity
- Observe and report concerns related to senior clients. The “OWN IT” program implemented at the speaker’s firm sets out actions and steps that can be taken to help protect seniors
What to do
The Aging Canadian Demographic
Delivered by: Goshka Folda, President and CEO – Investor Economics
Summary: Ms. Folda presents how Canadian demographics are shifting, the impact that these shifts are going to have on dealer business and the new risks and realities of senior clients and their finances.
- The senior demographic is growing quickly. By 2025, 1 out of 3 households in Canada will be a retiree household
- Median retirement age hasn’t really changed, but life expectancy has gone up significantly
- The pace of investment growth may not be enough for each Canadian to retire with the lifestyle they expect
- Household debt levels are increasing and will be a challenge for the boomer generation as they retire
- People are retiring later, not because they want to, but because they believe they need to in order to meet their retirement goals
- Conclusion: Given the demographic and economic shifts, what seniors may need going forward is more than investment advice but fully integrated wealth management to assist retirees with a broader spectrum of issues such as debt management, and estate and legacy planning.
FINRA and Seniors Issues
Delivered by: Dan Sibears, Executive Vice-President, Regulatory Operations/Shared Services – FINRA
Watch: FINRA and Seniors’ Issues
Summary: Mr. Sibears discusses best practices for seniors seen at FINRA member firms as well as FINRA’s seniors initiatives including their Securities Helpline for Seniors, and their proposed rules on trusted contact person and a safe harbour for temporary holds on disbursements.
Best practices regarding seniors issues seen at FINRA regulated firms:
- Policies and procedures regarding suitability specifically for seniors, including strict product concentration guidelines
- Development of seniors department within member firms – business processing, issue handling, trade review, etc.
- Requiring seniors continuing education courses
- Pre-approval for seniors designation usage
- Pre-approval for advisors to participate in unscripted seminars
Future FINRA Policy Initiatives (in place as of 2018):
- Trusted Contact Person: Firms to take reasonable efforts to obtain from clients the name and contact information of a trusted contact person who may be contacted if there are concerns regarding the financial exploitation of the client.
- Temporary Holds: If financial exploitation is expected and there is a request from a client to disburse funds from an account, a firm would have the ability to put a hold on disbursements for up to 15 days (with the ability to extend for another 15 days) while they conduct a reasonable inquiry into the concern.